Report: U.S. Suggests “NATO-like” Security for Ukraine; Russia Says “Nyet”
A recent report claims the United States has warmed up to the idea of Ukraine joining NATO in exchange for giving up territory to Russia. The idea has been verboten among the Americans, presumably because it was always a nonstarter for the Russians.
The Wall Street Journal reported Friday that President Donald Trump’s son-in-law and special envoy Jared Kushner “discussed the possibility [of NATO membership] with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and European officials at a Dublin military airfield last week.” The Journal is reporting this based on anonymous sources familiar with the talks. The idea “also came up in at least one meeting last week in the United Arab Emirates,” where Kushner and the other special envoy, Steve Witkoff, were meeting with the Ukrainians.
The NATO-inclusive proposal is one of two major suggestions that negotiators are kicking around. The Journal reported :
The first would require Ukraine to give up the territory it still controls in a region of eastern Ukraine known as the Donbas, where the two sides have been battling for much of the war, in exchange for full NATO membership. The second idea was to freeze the conflict along the front line — which would leave part of the Donbas territory in Ukrainian hands — and give Ukraine security guarantees to protect it from a future Russian assault through an international treaty with the U.S., and potentially with European allies.
Security for Territory
Earlier comments by Zelensky corroborate the Journal report. He said last Friday, “The Americans raised a question: ‘What if Ukraine joins NATO? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?’ This was the first time this had been raised.” Zelensky seemed open to the idea. He said:
If the American side confirms precisely this to us, together with other NATO partners, then I will ask our Ukrainian society what it thinks: do we accept it or not? I have no right to make that decision on my own. Of course, this would be without any recognition of the occupied territories as Russian. But we need specifics, and we don’t have them yet. All of this is still under discussion.
On Thursday, Kushner and Witkoff took part in a press conference with Zelensky and the heads of state for the United Kingdom, France, and Germany, who have been calling themselves the Coalition of the Willing. Kushner didn’t specifically say that NATO membership was on the table, but he did mention, multiple times, “Article 5-like” security guarantees. Kushner:
I think we’ve gotten the Russians comfortable with that concept, where any security guarantee with Ukraine would be based on Article 5.… From America’s perspective, giving an Article 5-like security guarantee is a really, really big deal. And I think that is something President Trump is open to. But, obviously, it has to be in America’s interest to do that. And we also have to make sure that it’s part of a broader security package in the sense that we discussed today with the Coalition of the Willing.… I do think a security guarantee has the potential to be a cornerstone of it and the goal is to make it as strong, as durable, and as good as possible. Not so you have to use it, but you make it so good that, hopefully, you never have to use it because the deterrence is so strong.
Kushner also said they’ve made progress “towards a pathway with Ukraine to the EU.”
Russian Rejection
Certain comments by Kushner and other leaders implied that the talks were getting somewhere. “Huge progress has been made,” U.K. Prime Minister Andy Burnham said. “Certainly in my time of office, I can see alignment coming here that is hugely helpful.” But in the end, Burham added, it’s ultimately up to Vladimir Putin.
The phrase “Article 5-like” refers to a collective defense pact. And the Russians’ response to the these recent suggestions of “NATO-like” security guarantees for Ukraine is the same as it was all the other times this idea came up: nyet.
Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov commented on the idea Friday, the day after the Berlin press conference. He called “quasi-membership in NATO” and any similar “creative solution” an “unacceptable option.” Russia wants a different guarantee, the assurance that Ukraine will not join NATO.
Putin shot down the idea of Ukraine joining NATO when he was in China for the trilateral summit with Trump and Chinese leader Xi Jinping. He called it “unacceptable,” adding:
We acknowledge that Ukraine has a right to security, just as Russia has. It is simply that no one wants to discuss Russia’s security, and that is a matter of considerable importance to us, to put it mildly.
Putin also reiterated the same grievance he has been going on about for more than a decade. When the Soviet Union broke up, Western leaders assured Russia that NATO would not expand eastward past Germany. “We were deceived then, and so it began — five or six waves of expansion. Ultimately, they reached Ukraine,” Putin said.
The Russians, if nothing else, are consistent. They still oppose Ukraine joining NATO, and they won’t accept a defensive pact under any other name.
Trump Scolds Europe
Meanwhile, Trump is reportedly scolding the Europeans for fueling the war by pouring piles of cash into Ukraine’s military. He said during a testy call with European leaders and Zelensky that “European governments were spending billions and billions supporting Ukraine when the money could instead benefit their own beautiful countries.” He said Putin was ready “to accept terms he previously would have rejected,” per reports. He said this after he had met with Putin in Shenzhen, China.
While the fog of war remains thick on the battlefield, the fog of peace talks refuses to let up among the men in suits.

