New Peer-reviewed Paper May Undermine Climate-change Alarmism
Parradee Kietsirikul/iStock/Getty Images Plus

New Peer-reviewed Paper May Undermine Climate-change Alarmism

The climate conference COP31, hosted under Turkey’s presidency with Australia leading negotiations, emphasizes turning prior commitments into measurable action: electrification targets, waste reduction, climate-resilient cities, and financing for developing nations. The summit continues the post-Paris Agreement focus on limiting warming through reduced fossil-fuel use and net-zero pathways. 

Negligible Effects

Undermining the basis for these policies may be a newly released peer-reviewed paper that found that the effects of industrial CO2 emissions are negligible on the atmosphere. The work, “Mathematical Falsification of the Fossil-Dominant Hypothesis for Rising Atmospheric CO2 Using the Keeling Relation,” appears in Science of Climate Change. Researchers used a specific graphical method called a Keeling plot to determine the source of carbon dioxide (CO2). They can identify the exact carbon “fingerprint” of CO2 being released into the air, automatically accounting for which sources are releasing the most gas.

Records evince stability in atmospheric CO2. The authors concluded that the fossil fraction of any atmospheric CO2 increase approaches zero in the long term. They argued this mathematically conflicts with the claim of U.S. and UN agencies that essentially all the post-industrial CO2 rise originates from fossil-fuel combustion.

Critics of climate alarmism framed the result as a “bombshell” and “total demolition” of the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) narrative, stating that fossil carbon’s contribution to the net rise is “effectively ZERO” or “negligible.”

Climate Alarmism

But the field of climate alarmism is very well funded and well entrenched, and its exponents reject this interpretation. They assert that multiple independent lines of competing evidence support the conclusion that human fossil-fuel emissions and land-use changes account for atmospheric CO2 increase.

For several decades, geopolitics and policy have treated man-made CO2 from fossil fuels as the dominant, urgent driver of dangerous warming. This premise has shaped energy transitions, carbon pricing, industrial regulations, catastrophe bond modeling, international finance transfers, and national security doctrines centered on “climate risk.” Trillions of dollars have been directed toward mitigation, energy systems in many countries have been restructured, and diplomatic capital has been expended at successive COPs.

No Existential Crisis

If the net atmospheric CO2 rise is driven primarily by natural fluxes (ocean outgassing or biosphere responses — as was attested in 1832 by geologist Charles Lyell and seems to be vindicated by the latest research), then the urgency and scale of those interventions rest on a weaker foundation than advertised. The modest atmospheric CO2 increase remains real, plants have benefited from higher concentrations (“global greening”), and local climate variability continues. But the causal chain — from fossil-fuel combustion to dominant CO2 forcing to existential crisis — would be substantially curbed.

However, COP31 will proceed with its implementation agenda irrespective of these facts.



This article is part of The New American’s weekly online newsletter Insider Report, which is emailed to TNA subscribers each week. Click here to subscribe to The New American to receive the Insider Report and access exclusive content.


Share this article

Rebecca Terrell

Rebecca Terrell is a senior editor and regular contributor for The New American.

View Profile