First Amendment Last? Colorado Law Can Compel “Trans” Speech
Andyborodaty/iStock/Getty Images Plus

First Amendment Last? Colorado Law Can Compel “Trans” Speech

The Colorado government spent a dozen years tormenting baker Jack Phillips, trying to compel him to be party to sexual devolutionary (“LGBTA+”) affairs. Court rulings, however, finally got the state off Phillips’ back in 2024. But far from learning its lesson, Colorado has now resumed wearing its dark hat, again compelling politically correct expression. The issue this time?

The state enacted a law last year that could force businesses to use “trans” pronouns. (This is even though people don’t have pronouns — languages do.) And now a lawsuit has been filed against the law by an enterprise whose very business involves rejecting such speech.

OutKick reported on the story Tuesday:

Jennifer Sey has a message for the state of Colorado: She doesn’t trust you, bro.

The founder of XX-XY Athletics, a company whose message centers on protecting women’s sports, is suing her home state over a law she believes could force her business to abandon the very language on which it was built.

The potential consequences aren’t insignificant. According to Hal Frampton, an attorney representing XX-XY Athletics who spoke with OutKick, violations of Colorado’s anti-discrimination law can carry fines of up to $3,500 per violation, while certain advertising violations can constitute a Class 2 misdemeanor punishable by up to 120 days in jail.

Granted, Colorado hasn’t taken any enforcement action against XX-XY Athletics since the law was passed in 2025. And that’s a central part of the state’s argument against granting the company legal protection while the lawsuit proceeds.

Sey, however, isn’t reassured.

… At issue is the Kelly Loving Act (HB 25-1312), a 2025 law expanding Colorado’s anti-discrimination protections to include a person’s chosen name and how that person chooses to be addressed — language Sey and her attorneys argue could require businesses to use pronouns and honorifics that conflict with their beliefs.

… She described the state’s argument as a “trust me, bro, defense …”

But Sey doesn’t trust the Colorado government. And why would she when the state spent 12 years putting Jack Phillips through a 1984-esque wringer?

More Significant Than It Even Seems

This story has wider implications than may be apparent. First, it reflects a warning many have long been issuing: Wokeness was never dead — only lying low.

Second, this cultural rot is precisely what Democrats will be pushing even more aggressively as their power grows.

Third, it illustrates how leftists are immune to reason. After all, the MUSS (Made-up Sexual Status, aka “transgender”) agenda has been repeatedly debunked, yet still it endures. Combating it is like playing whack-a-mole. The reason? The cultural substrate in which it flourishes has not been eradicated.

And fourth, the Colorado law reflects the universal leftist lust for controlling citizens’ tongues. These are the kind of thought police who’ve delivered speech codes on college campuses and elsewhere. They’d enact hate-speech laws of the kind prevalent in most of the Western world, too, if they could. Only our Constitution stands in their way — for now.

And the third and fourth points are related in that effecting positive cultural change requires infusing our institutions with Truth. A prerequisite for doing this, too, is being able to speak the Truth. Hence hate-speech laws’ value to the merchants of lies.

Haters of Reality

Apropos of this is something commentator Eric Utter wrote yesterday. Addressing the Rocky Mountain State’s rocky cultural state, he opined:

“Anti-discrimination law?”

The Colorado law is anything but a coercive government tool against discrimination. It is coercive, but is also preposterously discriminatory against the truth, the one thing we are Biblically charged with seeking … a.k.a., God.

In my humble opinion, everyone involved in passing this bogus law should themselves be fined and given jail time.

No human being has ever asked to be born. It just happens.

… Therefore, we cannot choose our own species, race, color, or ethnicity. Nor can we choose our own sex. XX or XY is stamped upon our every cell. Donning a dress or a string of pearls doesn’t make one a woman. Neither does lopping off one’s penis. Similarly, cutting off one’s breasts and sewing on something that may roughly resemble a phallus does not make one a man. These are clear signs of mental illness, not of a change of sex or gender.

Period. Full stop.

When the truth is put on trial, everyone loses in the long term. We can’t change it, no matter how we try. It is immutable. That’s why it is the truth.

Speaking of which brings us to a shocking fact. In certain countries, notably Germany, the truth of a statement is not, by itself, a complete defense against certain hate-speech offenses. As Copilot AI informs, illustrating the standards in Germany:

If someone says, “Group X committed crime Y at a higher rate than average,” and that claim is factually correct, that does not automatically shield the speaker from legal scrutiny if prosecutors argue the statement was used in a manner that incites hatred against the group.

Of course, this can make it easy for the authorities to find a pretext for squelching speech they dislike.

And how did we get to a point where the Truth can be secondary (if even that)? It’s at least largely a function of the moral-relativism/nihilism sweeping our time. This belief holds that Truth (objective by definition) does not exist; only social constructs — i.e., human preference — do. This makes all the difference.

For when you genuinely love Truth, you seek it, and you try to effectuate it. More to the point here, you also subordinate all else to it. When, let’s say, an ideological plank or a preference conflicts with the Truth, you discard it — even if doing so is emotionally displeasing.

Yet when you don’t believe in Truth (and most Americans today do not), what happens is simple.

You put something else in its place, an ideology, philosophy, etc. And absent Truth to use as a yardstick, this will often be emotionally determined (i.e., based on what “feels right”). Then, when an ideological plank or a preference conflicts with the Truth, you’ll rationalize away the latter. And why not?

For there’s then nothing above your emotions to dictate that one of their determinations is wrong. Put simply, whatever is taking the Truth’s place will have become your god.

And when your god is not God, evil is your guide.


Share this article

Selwyn Duke

Selwyn Duke (@SelwynDuke) has written for The New American for more than a decade. He has also written for The Hill, Observer, The American Conservative, WorldNetDaily, American Thinker, and many other print and online publications. In addition, he has contributed to college textbooks published by Gale-Cengage Learning, has appeared on television, and is a frequent guest on radio.

View Profile

Related News

Michael Tennant   Nov 14, 2026, 05:05 PM
Maryland Teacher: Abort All Boys to End “Oppression”
Selwyn Duke   Nov 13, 2026, 10:30 AM
A Grandma Calls America Back to God