Are Democrats Serious About “Gun Crime”?
RapidEye/iStock/Getty Images Plus

Are Democrats Serious About “Gun Crime”?

Imagine you know a guy who claims to want to lose weight and, consequently, replaces his regular pop with diet soda. But then he follows that beverage and a low-cal meal with copious amounts of cake and ice cream — every night.

Would you think he really was serious about shedding pounds? At best, he’s living in a world of rationalization.

There are real-life examples of related behavior, too. Just consider crime policy.

Imagine that certain politicians claim to want to reduce “gun crime” and that creating more related laws is the solution. (Society needs a gun diet, is their idea.) Yet at the same time, they stubbornly refuse to enforce the gun laws already on the books. (Ergo, the criminal part of society isn’t subject to the gun diet.)

Would you think they really were serious about wanting to quell “gun crime” — or about the idea that more laws are the solution?

Of course, you don’t have to imagine with this example. There are politicians coast to coast thus disposed.

Before addressing that, just a thought about our terminology. We hear much about “gun crime” and gunmen, and now even about “knife crime” and “knifemen.” But the FBI tells us, for instance, that more people are killed with “personal weapons” — defined as “hands, fists, and feet” — than with rifles of any kind.

So if someone is beaten to death, is it “fist crime” committed by a “fistman”?

If a person is stomped into a coma, is it “foot crime” perpetrated by a “footman”?

“My foot did it, your honor. I tried restraining him, but he was beyond reason and only wanted a hand … (or two).”

I mean, one could get the crazy idea here that we’re ignoring human agency. We’re putting an onus on the implement used — not on the user. But I digress.

Turnstile “Justice”

Returning to the matter of seriousness, fresh off a midterm machine-gunning of the GOP, the Democrats are pushing something they didn’t campaign on: tackling “gun crime” by restricting Second Amendment rights. But as the Washington Examiner asserts, essentially, they’re only serious about eliminating the rights, not the crime. Making its case, the site wrote Tuesday:

Congressional Democrats introduced more than a dozen bills in this Congress restricting the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms. If they want any of them to be taken seriously next year, they should show that they are genuinely interested in enforcing existing gun penalties by repealing Washington, D.C.’s Youth Rehabilitation Act.

In May, a 19-year-old D.C. resident armed with a pistol fired more than 20 rounds in the Petworth neighborhood of the nation’s capital, injuring a boy who had been playing basketball at a recreation center. Alerted to the shooting by ShotSpotter, police apprehended the suspect and searched his home, where they found two firearms, ammunition, and illegal drugs.

He pleaded guilty in May to aggravated assault and carrying a pistol without a license, convictions for which U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro requested a five-year prison sentence. But the judge used D.C.’s Youth Rehabilitation Act [YRA] to suspend the suspect’s sentence and release him on probation. He walked free last Friday.

It is an obvious travesty that a young adult man should get away with causing actual bodily harm by firing live rounds with an illegal gun. At the age of 19, the culprit can vote, a sign of society’s expectation that he be a responsible citizen. He was no longer a boy but was not obliged to take any responsibility at all.

The 19-year-old is not alone. The YRA empowers judges to sentence all eligible offenders who commit crimes before age 25 to less than the mandatory sentence. This can be problematic because, of course, young people constitute a high percentage of criminals. For example, more than 50 percent of suspects arrested for robbery are under-25s. It also appears likely that a majority of gang members are in that demographic.

Consequently, Pirro requested that the YRA, which was instituted in 1985 and expanded in 2018, be reconsidered. (She shouldn’t hold her breath waiting.) Making her case, she stated that eligible for YRA relief between 2022 and ’24 were:

  • 71 percent of armed carjacking defendants;
  • 69 percent of armed robbery defendants; and
  • 61 percent of defendants charged with assault with intent to kill.

The Examiner mentions that it’s ridiculous treating 24-year-olds like children. Equally ridiculous: Some of the same leftists want to give voting rights to 16-year-olds — and sometimes even younger kids. So minors should have adult authority, but, apparently, not adult responsibility.

If Not for Nonsense, It Wouldn’t Make Any Sense at All

Of course, the YRA is just one small aspect of leftists’ preferred slap-on-the-wrist criminal-justice model. And this model isn’t the only evidence of their lack of seriousness about crime committed with firearms. Consider just one other:

Leftists have long been on a crusade to ban so-called assault weapons; e.g., the AR-15. Yet these firearms are just a sub-category of rifles. And, as mentioned earlier, rifles as a group are used in fewer murders than are “personal weapons.” In other words, even eliminating every AR-15 wouldn’t move the homicide-rate needle one iota.

In contrast, handguns are used in 53 percent of gun-related murders. Moreover, they’re criminals’ firearm of choice because they’re concealable. So if you believed in gun-control and were sincere, wouldn’t you prioritize outlawing handguns over banning ARs? Note, too, that back in the ’80s and ’90s, handgun prohibitions were the focus.

Anyway, it’s all unserious enough to make one wonder: What is the goal here? Is it, to echo my earlier sentiments, the reducing of crime?

Or, is it the reducing of rights?


Share this article

Selwyn Duke

Selwyn Duke (@SelwynDuke) has written for The New American for more than a decade. He has also written for The Hill, Observer, The American Conservative, WorldNetDaily, American Thinker, and many other print and online publications. In addition, he has contributed to college textbooks published by Gale-Cengage Learning, has appeared on television, and is a frequent guest on radio.

View Profile