Missouri, Montana Declare Direct Democracy a “Fundamental Right”
In setbacks to a republican form of government, Missouri and Montana voters approved ballot measures on November 3 to amend their states’ constitutions to enshrine direct democracy as a “fundamental right.” Meanwhile, voters in other states, including North Dakota and South Dakota, rejected measures to limit direct democracy.
Missouri Amendment 6, which passed with nearly 60 percent of the vote, declares that “the rights of initiative and referendum as set forth in this Constitution are fundamental rights.” It prohibits the state Legislature from “weakening” those “rights” unless at least 80 percent of the members of each chamber vote to do so, and a majority of voters approve.
The amendment also enshrined a simple-majority threshold needed to enact state constitutional amendments. It declares that “a simple statewide majority of votes cast on the measure by individual legal voters shall be sufficient to enact any law or constitutional amendment proposed by initiative petition.”
Montana’s Constitutional Initiative No. 133 (CI-133), which passed with more than 65 percent of the vote, declares that “the people have a fundamental right to exercise their powers of initiative and referendum.” It states that “the government may not deny or burden this right unless justified by a compelling government interest achieved by the least restrictive means,” and defines specifically what the “right” entails.
Failing to Rein In Democracy
Meanwhile, ballot measures in other states to rein in direct democracy failed. For example, amendments in North Dakota and South Dakota to require a 60-percent popular-vote threshold for approving constitutional amendments — up from a simple majority — were rejected by 56.5 and 57.5 percent of voters, respectively. Additionally, a Utah ballot measure to increase the threshold to 60 percent for ballot measures that would raise or impose new taxes was rejected by more than 61 percent of voters.
Proposals in prior years to rein in direct democracy have also largely failed. Although Florida voters approved a proposal in 2006 to raise the approval threshold to 60 percent, similar measures in Arkansas (2022), Ohio (2023), and other states were defeated.
Direct Democracy vs. Limited Government
Direct democracy — especially Missouri’s and Montana’s amendments to constitutionally enshrine it as a “fundamental right” — threatens limited government. As we noted in our article “Restore State Government”:
While it may sound appealing, direct democracy is incompatible with the American form of government, enables mob rule, and makes it easier for governments to violate God-given rights…. In his 1961 speech Republics and Democracies, John Birch Society founder Robert Welch noted that the Founding Fathers created a system in which “laws … could not be changed without laborious and deliberate changes in the very structure of that government.” However, under direct democracy, it is easy to enact radical and poorly thought-out laws and constitutional amendments….
In particular, leftist groups and donors have used direct democracy to enact radical policies, including legalized abortion, ranked-choice voting, Medicaid expansion, and raising the minimum wage. These measures have often passed in conservative-leaning states whose legislatures would have rejected such proposals.
Missouri’s and Montana’s amendments also demonstrate how state constitutions have largely abandoned America’s founding principles. As our article explained:
While the U.S. Constitution, including its 27 amendments, has 7,591 words, the 50 state constitutions have on average about 39,000 words each. Vermont’s is the shortest at 8,565 words, while Alabama’s is the longest at 369,380 words (down from about 402,000 before a technical revision in 2022). The specific provisions of state constitutions are more important than raw word count, however, and they mandate state involvement in areas far outside the proper, God-given role of government. According to liberal Professor Jorge M. Farinacci-Fernós in a 2023 law-review article, “Many state constitutions are truly modern documents that address important social, economic, and political issues from a progressive perspective” and are “indispensable tools in the pursuit of progressive change.” For example, every state constitution mandates a government-education system, and many include provisions on organized labor, welfare, the environment, direct democracy, and positive “rights” that compel big-government action. Meanwhile, multiple state constitutions either have watered-down protections of the right to keep and bear arms or lack them entirely.
Founding Fathers on Democracy
Although Missouri’s and Montana’s constitutions now claim that direct democracy is a “fundamental right,” the Founding Fathers despised democracy and contrasted it with the American form of government. For example, James Madison asserted in The Federalist, No. 10, that democracy is “incompatible with personal security or the rights of property,” and John Adams wrote in an 1814 letter that “democracy never lasts long. It soon wastes, exhausts and murders itself. There never was a democracy yet, that did not commit suicide.”
Additionally, Elbridge Gerry, speaking at the 1787 Constitutional Convention, said that “the evils we experience flow from the excess of democracy.” And Alexander Hamilton, speaking at the 1788 New York Ratifying Convention, declared that “the ancient democracies, in which the people themselves deliberated, never possessed one feature of good government. Their very character was tyranny; their figure deformity.”
Instead of inventing “rights” that the Founding Fathers did not recognize, states must uphold America’s founding principles and restore a truly republican form of government in their constitutions.
This article is part of The New American’s weekly online newsletter Insider Report, which is emailed to TNA subscribers each week. Click here to subscribe to The New American to receive the Insider Report and access exclusive content.
