What Is AI? To Nail the AI Oligarchy, We Must First Demystify the Technology
Ilana Mercer
Ilana Mercer

What Is AI? To Nail the AI Oligarchy, We Must First Demystify the Technology

From the fact that there is nothing supernatural about AI software systems, it doesn’t follow that the alarmingly few characters in whose greasy palms the AI industry lies — who are pushing expansive applications of AI across societies — are not dangerously and impenetrably stupid.

There is no trap so deadly as the trap set by fools who think they are God.

Yes, it is necessary to clip the wings of the AI Icarus. Fast. And something else: Demystifying AI is an adjunct to the greater mission. The mission being to focus, more realistically, on the not-so-minor warts of the oligarchy that controls the AI industry, and on the “merry” life this monopoly plans for us, the great unwashed. 

But first, let us understand of what we speak. Plain speaking about AI (Artificial Intelligence) or AGI (Artificial General Intelligence) is what is sorely needed. And it is plain to see that there is nothing supernatural or mythical about AI.

Put it this way: I don’t plan on retreating, as yet, from my January 2025 simplified definition of AI. I’ll oblige if and when necessary. I put it to our readers, then, that it is “beyond silly to believe in the autonomy of artificial intelligence…. Artificial intelligence is nothing more than meta-programing by mega-programmers.”

Essentially, AGI is The Great Aggregator. The flabby assumption of absolute accuracy attributed to AI systems certainly needs challenging. Ron Unz, among others, provides the reader with instances of AI’s dangerous “hallucinations,” warning against promiscuous use of chatbots, in particular:

Many users increasingly regard AI chatbots as providing oracular wisdom, so they automatically accept those answers without second-guessing, especially if these responses include copious details. Unfortunately, chatbots still do sometimes hallucinate, with potentially very harmful consequences.

For these reasons, I usually restrict my own use of AI chatbots to simple and objective factual matters, while being cautious about questioning them on anything that is controversial or complex.

Indeed, subject-matter experts in my orbit have reported coming up sharp against AI chatbot replies that were wrong. The thing engaged fluidly with the problem, but then went on to spit out answers known by these experts to be incorrect.  

The medium is the message: By design, and as a function of the programing, AI systems generate soliloquies of information in no time. The confidence and speed with which AI engages with a problem induces blind faith.

No doubt, AI programs can certainly enhance the productivity of someone with a grounding in his subject matter. He knows what to take and what to discard. However, “While narrow AIs can be tremendously useful for specific tasks; when integrated into broad social contexts, their limitations become dangerous,” caution the authors of “A Brave New World: AI as a Nascent Regime?” in the Journal of Systemics, Cybernetics and Informatics.

One suspects, though, that warnings such as “A Brave New World: AI as a Nascent Regime?”, published only in 2023, might be too late. Ponderously conferring, in an interdisciplinary fashion, about the “threat of totalitarian control,” as the authors do, is just too late. The fat is in the fire. AI has already emerged “as a nascent regime powered by opaque algorithms, implemented by transnational, global companies.” That is a fait accompli.

Action and activism must now replace the conference.

This is something AI researcher Dr. Timnit Gebru understands. Gebru is a Stanford-trained engineer, whose love of the applied sciences has forced her into deconstructing the mythology around Artificial General Intelligence (AGI). By her telling, current AI myth-making errs in imputing to AI systems the quality of “recursive intelligence.” The phrase “recursive intelligence” denotes a system’s self-generating capability to improve itself. AGI has none, argues Dr. Gebru.

As someone who is vested in wedding language to reality — I think that the concept of large language models (LLMs), in particular, describes AI quite well, based, admittedly, on my limited reading — I think AI can reasonably be subsumed within the concept of a large language model.

Large language models, explains Emily M. Bender, lead author on a 2021 paper about LLMs, “generate text by statistically predicting likely sequences of words rather than understanding what they are saying” — a process the authors captured with the (unfortunate) metaphor of a “stochastic parrot”: “a system that repeats patterns without comprehension.” (“Unfortunate,” because parrots, Psittacines, are highly intelligent. They acquire speech through a cognitive process. Just like a toddler would, parrots associate a context with specific words. My Oscar-Wood associates and then utters words in a context. For example, he’ll lament, “Bye-bye, bye-bye,” when one leaves the house. He’ll say “kissy-kissy” in the context of a cuddle. Would a smart toddler say “go potty” when wanting a treat? Don’t be silly! Likewise, and appropriately, Oscar-Wood says “yummy-yummy” when we share our morning orange. How about we draw on our own species in search of analogies for stupidity, cupidity, and malevolence?)   

Back to Dr. Bender, a professor of computational linguistics at the University of Washington, who usefully also criticizes the term AI, which is actually a “general name for data systems, an LLM.” The “term AI comprises tons of disparate technologies and oversells what each one of them can do,” she cautions.

Although the 2021 paper aforementioned, “On the Dangers of Stochastic Parrots: Can Language Models Be Too Big?”, omits a discussion of AI’s implications for labor, the journal article examines the “risks of very large language models, including their environmental footprint, financial costs, [and] the inscrutability of [such] large models.” Mostly it has led to creative, critical, reality-based thinking about the ethics of AI and the cabal behind it.

So much so that Google deemed this 2021 scholarly collaboration sufficiently subversive to fire two of its authors. Employees Timnit Gebru, aforementioned, and Margaret Mitchell had questioned Google’s God of the Machine.

By stripping the bafflegab and the myth-making from AI, Dr. Gebru, heir to this laudable impetus, is also, as I see it, deconstructing the errors of anthropomorphism or the personification of machines, software and hardware. These errors cloud clear thinking by ascribing human qualities to inanimate things.

To be continued …

Related: “E. Musk: The AI Oligarchy Needs More Scrutiny Than The Technology”

SUBSCRIBE to “ILANA MERCER’S FPV Resistance” on Substack.

Ilana Mercer, a widely published paleolibertarian author, essayist and theorist, has been writing up an anti-war, anti-woke storm since 1998, starting in Canada. On arriving in the US, in 2002, her weekly column was right away syndicated. Mercer’s national syndication fell through shortly after due to writing in strident opposition to the war in Iraq. ILANA is described as “a system-builder. Distilled, her modus operandi has been to methodically apply first principles to the day’s events.” She’s Jewish, grew up in Israel ages five to nineteen, and left, at 19, decades back, never to return. She had refused to serve in the IDF, Israel’s compulsory military. Ilana’s focus since October of 2023 has been the Gaza genocide. Because it’s our duty.


Share this article

Ilana Mercer

Ilana Mercer has been writing a weekly, paleolibertarian think piece since 1999. Her new book is The Paleolibertarian Guide to Deep Tech, Deep Pharma & the Aberrant Economy (February, 2024) She’s the author of Into the Cannibal’s Pot: Lessons for America From Post-Apartheid South Africa (2011) and other books. Mercer is described as “a system-builder. Distilled, her modus operandi has been to methodically apply first principles to the day’s events.” Ilana, whose late father was a rabbi, grew up in Israel and was educated in part there. She speaks writes classical, literary Hebrew.

View Profile

Related News

John and Nisha Whitehead   Nov 05, 2026, 03:25 PM
Politicians Come and Go. The Machinery of Oppression Remains.
John and Nisha Whitehead   Oct 22, 2026, 04:04 PM
Vote As If the Constitution Depended on It